Archive Review: Tin Cup (1996)

Like the previous (and slightly better) Costner-Shelton collaboration of “Durham,” this film is a romantic sports comedy about a trashy/washed-up athlete who wastes a lot of talent and somehow manages to attract sexual attention.

Costner stars as West Texan Roy McAvoy, referred to sometimes as ‘Tin Cup,’ a talented college golfer who somehow ended up a golf pro at a downtrodden driving range with his amigo Romeo (Cheech Marin) while his college teammate David Simms (Don Johnson) went on to be a star. Roy is a betting man who goes with his gut, ignores reason and uses golf metaphors to make sense of life. When an anal retentive psychiatrist named Molly (Rene Russo) shows up at his range for lessons, Roy is smitten, only to find she’s with Simms. Of course the only way to win her over is to try and make the U.S. Open, right?

Costner and Russo have forced character chemistry. There’s no reason for either of them to be interested in each other, save that Roy wants a challenge compared to the white trash women he’s interested in. There’s certainly no reason for Molly to leave her tournament- winning boyfriend for a sleazeball. And you know it’s true when the dialogue directly addresses why they fell for the other like it’s justification or something.

The machismo fueling Roy and his buddies in the movie, constantly betting each other and insulting the other when he lays up and plays it safe is childish, but it brings the film its humor and keeps it from being a straight through underdog movie. Its more interested in its characters than building up plot suspense, which is a good thing, if only the characters behaved in realistic ways.

“Tin Cup” is a giant golf metaphor for life, about how taking risks — no matter how many times you fail — is always worth it. Shelton’s film is gutsy in the same way, finding different ways of telling a sports story that will make it feel different. It goes about it in an amateur way, but it’s the bravado that it will be remembered for. Shelton’s films have this miraculous tendency to only let their best parts stick with you. They’re the kinds of movies that make for great channel-surfing finds on TV. That’s really what “Tin Cup” is.